Best US Sports Tipsters | Top American Handicappers 2025

Since the US Supreme Court overturned the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act in 2018, it opened the door to a major expansion of legal online gambling. This shift has led to growing interest in American sports betting sites — and with it, a rising demand for US sports tipsters, often known as “sports handicappers.”

Historically, much of the US betting scene operated off the radar, making it harder to separate the serious tipsters from the hype. So where can you actually find reputable US sports handicappers worth following?

The list below features verified tipsters who specialise in popular American sports — offering insight and advice based on a proven track record.

Best Tipsters For US Sports

Ratings Explained

I evaluate US sports tipsters based on individual sports rather than grouping their results across multiple disciplines. This approach allows me to highlight each tipster’s specific area of expertise more accurately.

For example, if a multi-sport tipster performs particularly well in a sport like NFL, their strong results could be diluted when combined with less successful tips from other sports. By assessing each sport separately, it’s easier to identify where a tipster truly excels — helping you make better-informed choices based on specialist performance.

Exploring US Sports Betting & Picks

While the legal landscape is still evolving, tipsters — or “handicappers” as they’re often called in the US — have been part of the betting scene long before regulation. Much like their European counterparts, their goal is to gain an edge over the built-in bookmaker margin, often referred to as the “juice.”

The growth of legal betting has brought more attention to US sports markets, many of which are less saturated than Europe’s most competitive options, such as Premier League match odds and other popular football (soccer) markets.

But as always, it’s worth remembering that no tipster can guarantee success. There are risks — from inflated records to the inevitable variance that comes with betting. For a deeper look into this, see: Can Sports Tipsters Be Trusted?

Finding Value Is Key

The core principle behind beating the bookmaker is the same across all sports and regions: to succeed long-term, you need to bet at odds that offer genuine value.

Value betting means placing bets where the odds are higher than they should be — giving you a mathematical advantage over the bookmaker, also known as an “edge.” This doesn’t mean you’ll win every time, but over a large enough sample of bets, the goal is to generate a positive expected return.

While simple in theory, this concept is often misunderstood. Many bettors — even experienced ones — focus too heavily on picking winners without considering the odds being offered. This results in poor long-term performance, even when their predictions are fairly accurate.

Tipsters who consistently seek out value odds understand that betting is not about predicting outcomes alone — it’s about beating the market.

So when evaluating US sports handicappers, the question shouldn’t be “How many winners do they pick?” but rather “Do their selections offer long-term value?”

US vs European Tipsters

Leading on from the previous section, there are notable differences between tipsters operating in the more developed European online betting market, to those in the USA.

Proofing Services

Both Europe and the US offer third-party services designed to monitor the odds and profit achieved by bets advised by tipsters. While legitimate services exist in both regions, there are question marks surrounding the legitimacy and integrity of many US-based verification sites.

Platforms like PrecisionPicks, SportInvestorCentral, and VerifiedCappers have garnered mixed reviews, with some users reporting that these services:

• Display fake ‘handicapper profiles’.
• Are affiliated with a broader network of comparable sites.
• Include links to external sites supposedly ‘vetting’ them as a premium user — despite being hosted from the same location/IP address.

While I haven’t personally investigated these claims, exercising caution is advisable.

Find legitimate tipster verification services.

Sports Offered

The US market is passionate for various sports, particularly those native to the country. American Football (NFL), Basketball, and Baseball reign supreme in terms of TV viewership and revenue generation across North America. Consequently, it’s normal for US tipsters to focus their efforts on one or more of these sports.

In contrast, European tipsters typically concentrate on popular local sports. Betting on horse racing and following racing tips is a beloved pastime in the UK & Ireland, while football (soccer) is immensely popular throughout the continent. Although sports like rugby, tennis, cricket, and darts also receive attention, they are tipped to a lesser extent.

Unfortunately, American sports tips seldom take center stage in well-established European tipster services. This stands as one of the major drawbacks when considering predominantly Euro-centric tipster services.

Professionalism

Many US tipster services often lack the professionalism expected from a paid service.

These platforms are often cluttered with flashing banners, intrusive pop-ups, and excessive sales pitches, accompanied by images portraying lavish wealth and overly positive “reviews” that may not be entirely genuine.

While European tipster sites may exhibit similar attributes, the sector has undergone significant evolution over time. Many European services now prioritise transparency and professionalism. This shift can be attributed to several factors:

• Familiarity with Betting Scams: European punters have grown accustomed to encountering various betting scams. Consequently, they are more resistant to certain sales tactics commonly employed in the US.
• Regulatory Measures: European bookmakers are obligated to monitor their affiliates closely. This oversight helps curb unethical practices, such as affiliates posing as tipsters to exploit bettors.
• Increased Scrutiny: European tipster services face heightened scrutiny from both industry watchdogs and vigilant individuals on platforms like Twitter. This scrutiny ensures that dishonest practices are exposed promptly, leading to improved accountability within the sector.

While the US tipster industry may currently lag behind its European counterpart, there is potential for it to catch up over time. As awareness grows and regulatory measures are implemented, US tipster services may evolve to meet higher standards of professionalism and transparency.

Cost

There’s a notable difference in pricing between European and US tipsters.

In Europe, the majority of tipster services are reasonably priced, typically ranging from $0 to $50 per month. In stark contrast, many US tipster services command exorbitant prices, often reaching hundreds of dollars per month. This vast disparity in pricing raises concerns.

To illustrate, let’s consider a scenario where an individual invests $200 in a US tipster service per month, expecting a 15% ROI (which is considered exceptional). In this case, they would need to risk $1,333.33 just to break even. Clearly, this is not a great prospect for potential subscribers.

Considering I’ve taken a best-case ROI, it’s truly a wonder that such expensive US tipsters find business. However, I believe that over time, once more competition arrives to the online scene, tipster subscription prices will eventually trend downwards.

The available professional services are notably more competitively priced in Europe compared to the US.

Converting European Odds to Moneyline

If you’ve reached this point in my article, you might be wondering: “How can I follow European tipster services if I’m accustomed to US odds? And how do I convert Euro or UK odds to Moneyline?”

That’s a valid question. Converting odds to the US format can be crucial to ensure you can compare the quoted prices with those available on US betting sites.

There are two methods to convert the odds to your preferred format…

1. Use an Online Calculator

You can easily convert European (decimal) or UK (fractional) odds to Moneyline (and vice versa) using an online calculator.

I recommend using our odds converter.

2. Do it Manually

You can also convert American Odds into percentages yourself. This is a useful exercise because it gives a break-even % that you need to achieve long-term to win.

The most common odds in US sports are -110. To earn from your bets at these odds, you’ll need to win often enough that you turn 110 into 210 to overcome the “juice” (or “overround” as we call it in the UK).

Example 1: -110

You take $110 risked, and divide it by the ultimate $210 payout if you win, to get: .5238 or 52.38%.

• You must win at least 52.38% of your bets at -110 to break even.
• Dividing .5238 by 1 gives the Euro odds equivalent of 1.90

Example 2: +200

Now let’s say you have a +200 underdog. You take $100 risked and divide by the ultimate $300 payout if you win, and get .3333, or 33.33%.

• You must win 34%+ of the time to be profitable.
• Dividing .333 by 1 gives the Euro odds equivalent of 3.0

Also see my post: How to Convert Betting Odds Between Formats.

In the future there will be many more UK/European bookmakers offering their services to the US. So converting the odds will become much less of an inconvenience.

Want to Learn More About Tipsters?

To learn more about the risks and rewards in using tipsters, check out my articles:

• Will Tipsters Make Me Money?
• Twitter Tipsters — Do They Want You To Lose?
• Best Tipster Proofing Sites

Be sure to check out our basketball, american football and ice hockey betting guides for essential insights and tips.

• About
• Latest Posts

Toby @ Punter2Pro

Toby is the creator & writer of Punter2Pro. Drawing on his experience in developing value bet finders, Betfair bots, and other professional betting tools, he provides honest advice to help improve your approach to sports betting and safely navigate the murky waters of the online gambling world.

Latest posts by Toby @ Punter2Pro (see all)

• Bookmakers With The Highest Odds | Bookies With Best Prices - August 18, 2025
• The Most Reputable Bookmakers | Trustworthy Bookies - August 17, 2025
• Spread Betting | What Is A Spread Bet In Sports? - August 17, 2025