Best Tipsters For US Sports (American Handicapper Guide)

When the US Supreme Court struck down the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act in 2018, it opened the doors to (almost) an entire continent’s worth of sports punters.

As a result there’s been an increased interest in American sports betting markets, and by extension — US sports tipsters — better known as “sports handicappers”.

The problem is, so much US betting activity has taken place under the table, on the down-low up until now. So where exactly can you begin to find the best US sports tipsters? Who are the top US sport handicappers?

Featured in this article:


How to Identify A Top US Sports Tipster

The main principle used to identify a top US sports tipster is precisely the same for any other sport, including horse racing and soccer. Remember this:

Making a profit in betting means absolutely nothing if is isn’t proofed, or was generated over a very small (and insignificant) number of bets.

In other words, anyone can select a winning bet by chance. But only skilled handicappers can win in the longrun.

There’s undoubtedly the potential to earn from the US betting markets because of the vast array of sports and leagues available. Plus the fact that many of them are less competitive than hugely popular and efficient European soccer markets — such as Premier League match odds (1×2).

Unfortunately so many tipsters ‘bloat’ their profit records. So it’s very important to learn about the potential risks in using tipsters/handicappers, and to be aware that not everything is as glorious as it seems. I’ve written an article detailing everything you need to know, right here: Will Tipsters Make Me Money?

Having considered the risks, I have created a list of criteria by which I define my list of the best US tipsters:

  • Legitimacy — who collected the statistics? Are they trustworthy? Is the data correct and accurate?
  • Data set — is the data set large enough to know whether the tipster is profitable (or not)?
  • Profitability — how well has the tipster performed since starting out?
  • Frequency — how frequent are the tips? When are they usually released?
  • Recent performance — how well is tipster is doing right now?
  • Cost — how much does the tipster cost? Is it worth the investment?

Regardless whether you decide to subscribe to any of the recommended US sport tipsters in my list, always use the above criteria as a guideline.


Recommended US Sports Tipster Services

While there are many US-based handicapping services with impressive track records, I haven’t yet felt confident in recommending one for reasons I discuss in the US vs European Tipsters section of this article.

The following tipsters are members of reputable sites that I recommend for all sports. All tipster selections are verified to ensure that betting records have not been tampered with.

So, here’s my list of the best American sport tipsters…

1. USA Sports Wiseguys

USA Sports Wiseguys is, in my view, the top US sports tipster service on the Tipstrr platform. It specialises in Baseball and Basketball, with plenty of American Football selections — plus the occasional Ice Hockey tip thrown in.

Although the 4.5%+ ROI may not seem as impressive as some others tipsters you’ll find online, it was generated from a solid sample size of verified tips to back up the winnings. And proof is crucial. Furthermore, Wise Guys’ Basketball tips have made an ROI of over 6.5%; a performance level that the vast majority of Basketball-only tipsters will ultimately fail to maintain.

American Football is less frequently tipped by USA Sports Wiseguys, but so far they’ve maintained an ROI of over 7% from 300+ bets.


  • Legitimacy: Verified by Tipstrr
  • Data set: 3,150 bets since February 2018
  • Profitability: $3,617.04 profit (4.59% ROI, +144.68 units) from $25 flat stakes
  • Frequency: 30 tips per week, typically released throughout the day
  • Recent performance: $610.90 profit (7.88% ROI) over the past 3 months
  • Cost: €1 for 10 days, then £39/$49 per month

Last Updated: 02/03/2020. 


2. The NBA Tipster

As its name suggests, The NBA Tipster is a basketball-only tipster service.

Having joined Tipstrr back in 2017, the service has enjoyed many profitable months, with only one significant  blip back in December 2019. Despite this, the service holds an excellent ROI of well above 8%.

In the tipster’s own words: “this service aims to be selective and take the best plays, but volume may increase as the season goes on.”

The NBA Tipster recommends a starting bankroll of 75 Units, and 10/10 = 1 Unit Stake.


  • Legitimacy: Verified by Tipstrr
  • Data set: 1,302 bets since August 2018
  • Profitability: $892.76 profit (5.8% ROI, +35.71 units) from $25 flat stakes
  • Frequency: 6 tips per week, typically released 6pm-9pm game days
  • Recent performance: $113.00 profit (2.6% ROI) over the past 3 months
  • Cost: 7 days for free, then £29/$36 per month

Last Updated: 02/03/2020


3. NHL Betting Master

In December 2018, a tipster named Robert applied to the Betting Gods. He performed exceptionally well over a full season (46 weeks) of proofing, and earned his place on the site. The NHL Betting Master service was born.

NHL Betting Master focuses entirely on Ice Hockey. It’s a highly selective service, averaging only 21 tips per month. So far the service has produced a promising ROI of over 22% given the recommended £10 unit staking plan, from a sample size of over 300 bets.

While the ROI could reduce over time (and it comes in lower when applying flat stakes per bet), it appears that Robert has found an edge in the less-saturated NHL markets.


  • Legitimacy: Verified by Betting Gods
  • Data set: 319 bets since December 2018
  • Profitability: $2,970.4 profit (22.58% ROI, +297.04 units) from £10 unit stakes
  • Frequency: 21 tips per month, typically released between 4.30pm and 6.30pm
  • Recent performance: -$230.80 loss over the past 3 months from $10 unit stakes
  • Cost: £1.99/$2.50 for 15 Days, then £37/$47 Per Month

Last Updated: 02/03/2020. 


4. US Racing Expert

The US Racing Expert account is run by a tipster named James who completed 28 weeks of vetting from 6th June 2019 to 24th December 2019 before going public on Betting Gods.

US Racing Expert service specialises the US Horse Racing and, unlike many other services, recommends prices at SP (just before the race begins). This means there’s no struggling with the bookies to get on the odds advised.

James recommends a 100pts starting bank to keep your money protected. He has grown this by 109.94% so far — despite a recent dip in form. Based on previous performance, you might expect his results to pick up through 2020.


  • Legitimacy: Verified by Betting Gods
  • Data set: 685 bets since June 2019
  • Profitability: $1,099.33 profit (13.55% ROI, +109.94 units) from $10 unit stakes
  • Frequency: 69 tips per month, typically released between 7.00am and 9.00am
  • Recent performance: -$573.68 loss over the past 3 months from $10 unit stakes
  • Cost: £1.99/$2.50 for 15 days, then £27/$34.50 per month

Last Updated: 02/03/2020


5. The Bookie Smasher

The Bookie Smasher is a mixed sports service offering a few US sports including Hockey and Basketball, as well as a lot of tennis picks. Although not limited to MLS fixtures, the service does include a lot of soccer tips, too.

Every day the tipster behind The Bookie Smasher, Raffaele, analyses a whole variety of sports markets looking for value. By covering a range of sports and markets, he’s able to produce a higher-than average number of selections per month.

Raffaele recommends a 50pts starting bank to keep your money protected. The service has made a slow start to 2020, but holds a solid enough overall record to suggest the tide might turn.


  • Legitimacy: Verified by Betting Gods
  • Data set: 1,748 bets since May 2019
  • Profitability: $1,099.30 profit (6.37% ROI, +219.86 units) from £10 unit stakes
  • Frequency: 159 tips per month, typically released Monday to Sunday between 10.00am and 12.00 noon
  • Recent performance: -$188.30 loss over the past 3 months
  • Cost: £1.99/$2.50 for 15 days, then £27/$34.50 per month

Last Updated: 02/03/2020


Also check out…

  • ‘Safe Bets’ on Tipstrr. The service currently holds an excellent record for American Football and Basketball, but its overall profitability has been let down by a poor run of form in football (soccer).
  • ‘Tee And Serve Tips’ on Betting Gods. This service focuses entirely on Golf and Tennis. It holds one of the most impressive records on the Betting Gods network — but it’s not very ‘American’ and hence it didn’t make my top 5 list above. Nonetheless, it ticks a lot of boxes, and is well worth trialling.
  • Horse Racing tipsters from Europe. Currently horse racing has the strongest selection of tipsters. If you’re ready to venture away from US sports, then UK/Irish horse racing is a great staring point.


US vs European Tipsters

I think it’s important to recognise the differences between tipsters operating in the more developed European online betting market, to those in the USA.


Despite (legal) online betting being new to the US, tipsters have long existed in America. They’re commonly known as “handicappers”, or “cappers” for short. Just like “tipsters”, they quantify the results of a sporting event in order to overcome the profit margin — or “juice” — integrated into sports betting odds.

Fundamentally, the same rules apply to any sport you decide to bet on — including those from the US. This rule is very simple, yet vastly overlooked:

You need an advantage, also known as an “edge”, in your favor in order to profit from sports betting. You achieve an advantage by consistently betting on value odds.

Betting on value, over a large set of bets — with ups and downs included — will result in a positive ROI. But truth be told, this message doesn’t get through to a lot of bettors no matter how long they’ve been at it. Most experienced bettors from Europe still try to “pick winners” every event, and end up losing over time.

Both Europe and US based tipsters regularly neglect to mention the importance of finding value prices. Many of them instead brag about their win rates without ever mentioning that this alone does not guarantee a profit, until you consider what odds were achieved. It’s a huge problem in the tipster/handicapper scene.

Learn more about value betting.


In both Europe and the US there are third party services designed to monitor the odds and profit achieved on every bet advised by Tipsters.

For an array of sports, I recommend three tipster proofing services: TipstrrSmart Betting Club and Betting Gods. I cannot vouch for anything else currently. Using them is the best way (I’ve found) to be confident of a tipster’s historical record.

Indeed you can find some third party tipster verification sites in the US — such as PrecisionPicks, SportInvestorCentral and VerifiedCappers. But there are question marks surrounding their legitimacy and integrity. While some customer reviews are positive, others claim that one or more of them:

  • Features ‘handicapper profiles’ which aren’t real.
  • Are part of a much larger network of similar sites.
  • Links to external sites supposedly ‘vetting’ them — yet they’re hosted from the same location.

I haven’t been able to verify these claims, but it’s worth being cautious. It’s a minefield out there.

Legitimate Tipster Verification Services

Sports Offered

The US is fanatical about several sports — especially their own ones. American Football (NFL), Basketball and Baseball dominate in terms of TV viewing figures, and the revenue they generate across North America. So it’s common for US tipsters to target one or more of those sports.

Likewise, European tipsters tend to focus on popular local sports. Betting on horse racing tips is something of a sports betting pastime in the UK & Ireland, and following football (soccer) tips remains enormously popular across the entire continent. Rugby, tennis, cricket and darts are tipped — but to a much lesser extent. American sports tips are, unfortunately, rarely the focal point of well-established European tipster services.

Most experienced US sports handicappers, as you might expect, run in very different circles to European tipsters. They’re generally located in America — where there’s the biggest demand for their picks. So while US bettors have the choice to use a safer and more established European tipster service, a US-based service will no doubt provide many more localised American sports tips.


Without sounding too judgmental, many US tipster services lack the professionalism you’d want to see from a service you’re expected to pay good money for.

Many US tipster sites are bombarded with flashing banners, popups, sales spiel, images of extravagant wealth, and overly positive “reviews” that we’re supposed to believe are legitimate. It’s hard to see past the sleaziness and poor presentation.

There’s no doubt that European tipster sites share many of those same attributes — but the sector has evolved over time, and many services offer a much higher level of transparency and professionalism. This is due to a number of reasons, such as:

  1. Players becoming accustomed to betting scams. Some of the sales tactics currently used in the US would receive more resistance in Europe. Punters have seen it all before. There’s a legacy of disappointment.
  2. Bookmakers are obliged to monitor their affiliates. For many years European gambling affiliates have posed as tipsters in order to profit from the very people they’re “advising” on picks. They still do — but this is being clamped down on, in line with stricter regulations (particularly in the UK).
  3. European tipster services are scrutinised more than ever before. A number of sites and individuals (especially on Twitter) monitor tipster results in order to expose liars and fraudsters. Dodgy services are identified more quickly than ever before.

The US appears to be behind the curve. In time, it’ll catch up.


Perhaps the most striking difference between European tipsters and US tipsters is the pricing. I’ve seen some extortionately high subscription prices for American tipster services.

The majority of European tipster services are priced between $0-$50 per month. At times, I’ve questioned whether these (comparatively low) subscription prices are worthwhile given the ROI players would be aiming to achieve from the services. Yet in the USA, many tipster services are priced at hundreds of dollars per month. It raises alarm bells.

Let’s put tipster subscription prices into perspective. If you spend $200 on a tipster service per month, and assume that your tips will guide you to a 15% ROI (the best I’ve ever witnessed over a large sample), then you’d need to risk $1,333.33 to expect to break even. Its not a great prospect.

Considering I’ve taken a best-case ROI, it’s truly a wonder than such expensive US tipsters find business. However, I believe that over time, once more competition arrives to the online scene, tipster subscription prices can only go down.

While Europe still has a long way to go in tipster proofing, the professional services available are more competitively priced.


Converting European Odds to Moneyline

If you’ve made it this far through my article, you might be wondering: “how can I use European tipster services when I’m accustomed to US odds? How can I convert the Euro/UK odds over to Moneyline?”

Good question. It could be vitally important that you convert odds over to the US format so that you’re able to match up the prices quoted to those offered on US betting sites.

So there are two ways to convert the odds over to your familiar format…

1. Use an Online Calculator

You can easily convert European (decimal) or UK (fractional) odds to Moneyline (and vice versa) using an online calculator. I recommend Ace Odds.

Note that all odds formats represent a percentage chance of an event occurring. Your aim as a punter is to beat those percentages (perhaps by using a tipster service), in order to generate a profit.

2. Do it Manually

You can also convert American Odds into percentages yourself. This is a useful exercise because it gives a break-even % that you need to achieve long-term to win.

The most common odds in US sports are -110. To earn from your bets at these odds, you’ll need to win often enough that you turn 110 into 210 to overcome the “juice” (or “overround” as we call it in the UK).

Example 1: -110

You take $110 risked, and divide it by the ultimate $210 payout if you win, to get: .5238 or 52.38%.

  • You must win at least 52.38% of your bets at -110 to break even.
  • Dividing .5238 by 1 gives the Euro odds equivalent of 1.90

Example 2: +200

Now let’s say you have a +200 underdog. You take $100 risked and divide by the ultimate $300 payout if you win, and get .3333, or 33.33%.

  • You must win 34%+ of the time to be profitable.
  • Dividing .333 by 1 gives the Euro odds equivalent of 3.0

Also see my post: How to Convert Betting Odds Between Fotmats.

In the future there will be many more UK/European bookmakers offering their services to the US. So converting the odds will be become much less of an inconvenience.


Want to Learn More About Tipsters?

To learn more about the risks and rewards in using tipsters, check out my articles:

I’m also currently monitoring the progress of proofed tipsters for football (soccer) and horse racing, using verified data from Tipstrr. Check out my posts to find monthly updates for each sport:


Toby @ Punter2Pro
0 0 vote
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments