Considering a career as a professional Betfair trader? Be prepared: consistently profiting on Betfair is extremely demanding. Even skilled traders encounter significant obstacles that can derail their progress without discipline, adaptability, and persistence.
Below are the 10 biggest challenges faced by Betfair traders.
Article Contents
1. Fierce Competition
Betfair traders operate in a highly competitive market, where one trader’s success often comes at another’s expense. Every opportunity you find is simultaneously being hunted by others — including professionals, algorithms, and bots.
I’ve developed strategies that profited over thousands of bets, only to see them become ineffective. Did the edge disappear? Perhaps. But I believe some of those strategies were simply uncovered and exploited by competitors — as shown in this example.
To survive, you must stay alert. Vary your stake sizes and timings, avoid predictability, and stay one step ahead of your rivals.
2. The Accuracy of the Markets
Many newcomers underestimate just how efficient Betfair markets are.
If you placed a series of random, equal-stake bets, you’d likely break even or lose just a small percentage over time. That’s because betting exchange users, collectively, are highly effective at pricing markets — especially in high-liquidity events.
To beat the market, you must test your theories over a large sample and demonstrate a genuine ability to identify mispriced outcomes. Without that, even the best-structured strategies won’t hold up in the long term.
3. Dealing with Back-Lay Spreads
On Betfair, there’s always a spread — the gap between Back and Lay odds. The true “fair” price typically lies somewhere in between. For example, if the Back price is 3.00 and the Lay is 3.15, then the fair price might be around 3.07.
To gain value, you need to get matched within the spread — not outside it. But that’s easier said than done. At higher odds, or in thinly traded markets, you may not get matched unless you move your price to a less favourable level.
This is where many traders go wrong. They assume that because their Back bets lost money, the Lay side must have been profitable. But they overlook the impact of poor execution — especially if they’re Laying at inflated odds without controlling for liability.
Mastering odds execution — and understanding how the spread affects your value — is essential to profitable trading.
4. Battling Against Bots
The exchange is filled with automated trading bots — and many are extremely fast and sophisticated.
Some bots provide liquidity through Market Making. Others cause chain reactions, manipulate the weight of money, or rapidly shift odds through reactive price chasing. There are even bots designed to mimic human traders while moving inside the spread to grab optimal prices.
As a trader, you must learn to recognise which moves are real and which are artificial. Many bots are designed specifically to provoke responses from human traders. If you misinterpret these movements, you’ll find yourself trading on false signals — and that’s a recipe for consistent losses.
5. Scaling Up Your Stakes
Most traders begin with small stakes — often the minimum £2 — to test strategies safely. But when scaling up, new problems emerge.
Larger stakes can disrupt the market. They attract attention from other traders and bots, trigger liquidity shifts, or skew the odds. Even worse, favourable odds may only be partially matched, while unfavourable ones are filled instantly.
To avoid this, try matching smaller chunks (e.g. 4 × £50 rather than one £200 bet), use stealthier entry points, and avoid creating price pressure that backfires.
Scaling isn’t just about staking more — it’s about doing so without signalling your intentions to the market.
6. Commission Eating into Profits
Betfair’s commission might seem modest at 2% to 5%, but in trading, it adds up fast.
Take my Mug Betting Experiment as an example. It produced a +3.77% ROI before commission — but dropped to exactly 0.00% after applying Betfair’s standard fee. In a field where marginal gains matter, that difference was everything.
Always factor in commission when evaluating or back-testing a strategy. If the margin is too thin to absorb the charge, you don’t have an edge.
7. Unmatched Bets and Execution Risk
If your bets are often unmatched, you may be asking for unrealistic prices — or placing stakes too large for the market depth.
In fast-moving markets, opportunities disappear quickly. You’ll need sharp tools and rapid decision-making to capture them. I recommend using specialist Betfair software and bots to speed up your execution.
You can also improve by learning to interpret Betfair’s volume charts — a skill covered in this excellent tutorial from Caan Berry.
Most importantly, practice. Start by monitoring how and when you get matched. From there, fine-tune your staking, pricing, and timing.
8. Avoiding In-Play Temptation
Pre-event trading works best when you stick to your rules. But many traders fall into the trap of letting their positions roll into in-play, hoping for a turnaround.
Once an event begins, everything changes: markets become volatile, liquidity dries up, and your carefully planned trades lose relevance. Worse still, emotions take over — especially when chasing losses.
Disciplined traders use features like automatic cancellation of unmatched bets at the off. They avoid becoming emotionally attached to a trade and don’t let “hope” dictate decisions.
If your edge is pre-event, keep it that way. Letting trades drift into in-play turns strategy into speculation.
9. Learning to Cut Losses
Scratch trades — where you Back and Lay at the same odds — are often seen as disappointing. But they’re an essential tool for managing risk.
If the market turns against you, exiting for no gain or loss is a smart move. It protects both your bankroll and your mental capital — allowing you to trade with clarity and confidence.
Yes, it’s frustrating when the market moves in your favour just after you’ve exited. But the alternative — holding on too long and suffering bigger losses — is far worse.
Being able to accept scratch trades is part of the mindset shift needed to become a consistent trader.
10. Facing the Premium Charge
Even if you overcome all the challenges above and become profitable, Betfair’s Premium Charge looms large.
It’s a fee levied on Betfair’s most successful users, raising their commission rate to 20%, 40%, 50%, or even 60% depending on earnings.
That means the more you win, the more Betfair takes. For some traders, this makes long-term success unsustainable — and switching to another exchange like Matchbook becomes the only viable option.
Ready to take on the challenge of becoming a professional sports trader? Here are the sites I recommend signing up with:
- Lotteries | What Are Lottery Games? Which Bookies Offer Them? - May 7, 2025
- LeoVegas Review | Is The Sportsbook Worth Using? [2025] - May 7, 2025
- Why One Tipster Isn’t Enough: The Power of Expert Consensus - May 7, 2025